Criminal Defense North Texas
When you are facing criminal charges, the legal process can feel overwhelming and opaque. One of the most critical components of your defense is “discovery”—the process by which the defense receives evidence from the prosecution.
At Beltz Law Group, we believe an informed client is an empowered client. However, Texas law imposes very specific rules regarding how evidence is handled. Below, we outline your rights to see the evidence against you and the legal limitations placed on your attorney regarding the distribution of those materials.
The Right to Evidence: The Michael Morton Act
In Texas, the rules governing discovery are primarily found in Article 39.14 of the Texas Code of Criminal Procedure, also known as the Michael Morton Act. This law requires the state to disclose evidence to the defense that is material to any matter involved in the action. This includes police reports, witness statements, and any exculpatory evidence (evidence that might prove your innocence).
Viewing vs. Possessing: The Limitations of Article 39.14(f)
While the law ensures that your legal team has access to the prosecution’s file, there is a significant distinction between a defendant’s right to view evidence and their right to possess it.
Under Article 39.14(f) of the Texas Code of Criminal Procedure:
“The attorney representing the defendant… may allow a defendant, witness, or prospective witness to view the information provided under this article, but may not allow that person to have copies of the information provided, other than a copy of the witness’s own statement.”
Criminal Defense North Texas
What This Means for You
-
The Right to View: You have an absolute right to review the discovery materials with your attorney. At Beltz Law Group, we prioritize sitting down with our clients to go over the evidence, including body camera footage, police narratives, and forensic reports. Understanding the state’s case is vital to making informed decisions about your defense.
-
The Restriction on Copies: Your attorney is legally prohibited from giving you physical or digital copies of the discovery materials to keep for yourself. You cannot take these documents home, nor can your attorney email them to you for your personal possession.
-
The Only Exception: The law provides a singular exception: a witness (including the defendant) is permitted to receive a copy of their own recorded or written statement.
Why Do These Restrictions Exist?
The Texas Legislature implemented these restrictions primarily to protect the privacy and safety of victims and witnesses. By preventing defendants from possessing copies of discovery, the law seeks to reduce the risk of sensitive information (such as addresses, phone numbers, or witness identities) being shared outside of the legal proceedings or used for intimidation.
The Attorney’s Professional Responsibility
Criminal Defense Attorney
It is important to understand that these limitations are not a choice made by your lawyer, but a strict mandate of Texas law. If an attorney provides a client with copies of discovery in violation of Article 39.14(f), they could face professional disciplinary action or even be held in contempt of court.
How Beltz Law Group Navigates These Rules
Our priority is ensuring that you are fully aware of every piece of evidence in your case while remaining in total compliance with the law. We facilitate evidence review through:
-
In-office review sessions where we analyze documents and media together.
-
Detailed discussions regarding the strengths and weaknesses of the state’s evidence.
-
Strategic planning based on the contents of the discovery file.
If you have questions about your case or the evidence being held by the state, the experienced team at Beltz Law Group is here to help you navigate the complexities of the Texas criminal justice system.
Disclaimer: This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. For specific guidance regarding your criminal case, please consult with a licensed attorney.
