It is a frequent point of frustration for Texas drivers and defense attorneys alike: you walk into a municipal or justice court with a high-speed citation, only to be told by court staff or the judge that the court has a “blanket policy” denying deferred disposition for anyone traveling more than 20 or 25 mph over the posted limit.
While high speeds certainly carry increased safety risks, Texas law is clear on this matter: there is no statutory speed threshold that categorically disqualifies a driver from seeking deferred disposition. When a judge enforces a rigid, predetermined policy refusing to even consider deferred disposition based solely on the speed on the ticket, they may be committing a serious constitutional error. Under Texas law, such a blanket refusal violates a defendant’s due process rights and can serve as grounds for a motion for recusal or an outright reversal on appeal.
The Governing Law: What the Texas Statutes Actually Say

Speeding Ticket Lawyer North Texas
Deferred disposition in Texas justice and municipal courts is primarily governed by Texas Code of Criminal Procedure Article 45A.302 (formerly Article 45.051). This statute establishes that if a defendant enters a plea of guilty or nolo contendere (or is found guilty) of a misdemeanor punishable by a fine only, the judge may defer further proceedings for up to 180 days without entering an adjudication of guilt. Because standard speeding violations are fine-only offenses under Texas Transportation Code § 542.401, they strictly fall within the purview of this statute.
The legislature explicitly outlined the strict exceptions to this rule in Article 45A.301. Deferred disposition is legally unavailable only if:
-
The offense occurred in a construction or maintenance work zone with workers present (per Transportation Code § 542.404).
-
The defendant held a Commercial Driver’s License (CDL) at the time of the offense or holds one currently.
The Key Takeaway: Noticeably absent from Article 45A.301 is any mention of speed. The law does not state that traveling 90 mph, 100 mph, or 30 mph over the limit bars a driver from eligibility. The statutory exclusions are based strictly on location (work zones) and license status (CDL holders)—not velocity.
Discretion vs. Blanket Exclusions: The “Full Range of Punishment” Doctrine

Speeding Ticket Defense Attorney
It is vital to distinguish between a judge lawfully exercising their discretion and a judge implementing an unconstitutional court policy.
As the Texas Fourteenth Court of Appeals clarified in Hassan v. State (2012), deferred disposition is a matter of judicial discretion, not an absolute right. A judge is entirely within their legal authority to listen to the facts of a high-speed case, evaluate the driver’s history, and decide that the severity of the speed warrants a denial of deferred disposition.
What a judge cannot do is refuse to even entertain the request.
Under Texas constitutional law, a defendant has an absolute right to be sentenced by a judge who considers the full range of punishment. In the landmark case Grado v. State (2014), the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals ruled that the right to an open-minded judge who considers the entire range of punishment is a fundamental, non-forfeitable right. This means a judge has an independent, mandatory duty to genuinely consider all lawful sentencing options—including deferred disposition—unless the defendant explicitly waives that right.
What Happens When a Judge Uses a Predetermined Policy?
When a court adopts an unwritten rule stating, “We never grant deferred for speeds over 95 mph,” it is arbitrarily lopping off a portion of the lawful punishment spectrum before hearing a single shred of evidence. Texas appellate courts have repeatedly struck down this type of behavior:
-
In Cabrera v. State (2016), the court ruled that a trial judge violates due process when they indicate, prior to hearing evidence, that a certain lenient sentencing option is off the table.
-
In Hernandez v. State (2008), a due process violation was found because a judge applied a personal, predetermined sentencing formula rather than evaluating the specific facts of the individual case.
-
As summarized in Roman v. State (2004): “A court denies a defendant due process when it arbitrarily refuses to consider the entire range of punishment or imposes a predetermined punishment.”
If a judge openly states on the record that their court simply does not allow deferred disposition past a certain speed, they have effectively exposed their judgment to being overturned on appeal.
Practical Consequences: Recusal and Appeals

Speeding Ticket Defense Attorney
While appellate courts generally presume a judge acted fairly unless the record explicitly proves otherwise (Cabrera v. State), a clear statement of a blanket policy shatters that presumption. For drivers facing high-speed allegations, this legal framework creates two vital avenues of defense when dealing with an unyielding court:
1. Grounds for Recusal
If a judge openly acknowledges a personal or institutional policy that forecloses the statutory option of deferred disposition based purely on speed, they are failing to provide an impartial forum. A defense attorney can leverage this as an indication of bias or a refusal to follow the law, creating a valid foundation for a motion to recuse the judge.
2. Issues Preserved for Appeal
Because Grado v. State designated the right to have the full range of punishment considered as a “waivable-only” right, a defendant does not even have to object at the time of trial to preserve this error. If the record clearly reflects that the court utilized a predetermined, arbitrary speed threshold to deny deferred disposition, the issue can be raised for the very first time on appeal. Furthermore, recent procedural developments, such as the Court of Criminal Appeals’ decision in State v. Cuarenta (2025), highlight that deferred disposition mechanics remain highly litigated and actively scrutinized by upper courts.
Balancing Public Safety with Constitutional Due Process
To be clear, the law does not force a municipal or justice court judge to hand out deferred disposition to every driver clocked at 100 mph. Judges are expected to weigh public safety, general deterrence, and driver history.
However, the Constitution demands an individualized assessment. Every driver is entitled to a fair hearing where the judge actively listens to the unique mitigating circumstances of the traffic stop before rendering a decision.
If you or a loved one has been cited for a high-speed violation in Texas, do not let an informal court “rule” strip away your statutory options. At Beltz Law Group, we understand the nuances of the Texas Code of Criminal Procedure and are dedicated to ensuring that the courts respect your constitutional right to due process. Contact our office today to ensure your case is evaluated on its individual merits—not an arbitrary policy.





