Criminal Defense North Texas
In a criminal defense case, information is power. The process by which the prosecution shares its evidence with the defense is known as discovery. In Texas, this process is governed by strict statutory rules and constitutional mandates designed to ensure a fair trial.
At Beltz Law Group, we believe every defendant deserves to know exactly what evidence the State intends to use. However, the timing and scope of this disclosure depend heavily on the stage of your case.
The “Line in the Sand”: Pre-Filing vs. Post-Filing
One of the most common questions clients ask is, “Can we get the police reports before I’m even charged?” In Texas, there is a clear legal distinction between when the State can share information and when it is required to do so.
1. Pre-Filing: The Investigative Phase
Before an indictment or “information” (the formal charging document) is filed, the State has no statutory obligation to share discovery.
According to the Texas Court of Appeals in In re State ex rel. Munk (2015), district courts do not even have the jurisdiction to compel the State to produce discovery in unindicted cases. The court reasoned that a formal charge is “essential” to the court’s authority. Essentially, until you are formally charged, the law does not provide a mechanism to force the prosecution’s hand.
2. Post-Filing: The Michael Morton Act
Once formal charges are filed, the landscape shifts dramatically. Article 39.14 of the Texas Code of Criminal Procedure (the Michael Morton Act) kicks in, creating a comprehensive duty for the State to disclose its file.
When and What Must the State Share?
Criminal Defense Lawyer North Texas
Under Article 39.14, the State must produce evidence “as soon as practicable” after receiving a timely request from the defense.
Key Disclosure Requirements:
-
General Evidence: Offense reports, witness statements, photographs, and tangible objects material to the case.
-
Exculpatory Evidence (Brady Material): Under Article 39.14(h), the State has an affirmative, ongoing duty to disclose any information that tends to negate your guilt or reduce your punishment. This must be shared even if the defense doesn’t ask for it.
-
Expert Witnesses: If requested 30 days before trial, the State must disclose expert witness info no later than 20 days before jury selection.
The “State” Includes Law Enforcement
A landmark 2024 ruling, State v. Heath, clarified that “the State” doesn’t just mean the prosecutor—it includes the police and law enforcement agencies. Prosecutors cannot claim they “didn’t know” the police had a certain piece of evidence; they have an affirmative duty to search for and produce it.
Legal Standard: “As soon as practicable” means “reasonably capable of being accomplished.” Prosecutors must act with diligence, as the law intends for disclosure to be the rule and non-disclosure the exception (Watkins v. State, 2021).
Summary of Relevant Case Law
| Case | Key Takeaway |
| In re State ex rel. Munk (2015) | Courts cannot force the State to provide discovery before an indictment is filed. |
| Watkins v. State (2021) | Article 39.14 is broader than constitutional requirements; disclosure is the default rule. |
| State v. Heath (2024) | Prosecutors have a duty to search law enforcement files; “bad faith” is not required for a court to sanction the State for late discovery. |
Constitutional Protections: The Brady Rule
Criminal Defense Attorney
Beyond Texas statutes, the U.S. Constitution provides the Brady Obligation. The State must disclose evidence favorable to the accused. If they disclose it late, Texas courts (such as in Ortiz v. State) look at whether the defendant still had enough time to use that evidence effectively at trial.
How We Protect You
At Beltz Law Group, we aggressively pursue discovery the moment a case is filed. We hold the State accountable to the “as soon as practicable” standard established in Heath, ensuring that no evidence—whether held by a detective or a prosecutor—remains hidden.
If you are facing charges and want to ensure your rights to evidence are being protected, contact us today to discuss your defense strategy.
